{
"evaluationState" : {
"id" : "c66038d1-e7ba-456c-9e63-7008f6b513a3",
"startTime" : "2026-09-12T10:51:47.162344Z",
"endTime" : "2026-09-12T10:53:46.223328Z",
"status" : "SUCCESS",
"commitHash" : "169807940fe2e83579f4a1a12f6a4dadf530cd27"
},
"stepResults" : {
"llm" : {
"notification" : "",
"feedbacks" : {
"sorting" : {
"hasChanged" : true,
"feedback" : "##### Correctness\n- \n\n##### Suggestion\n- \n\n##### Code Style\n-\n"
}
},
"feedback" : null,
"status" : "SUCCESS"
},
"structure" : {
"name" : "main",
"similarityToProf" : 0.4970933556967199,
"codeComplexity" : 0.4655437522502508,
"programmingTime" : 0.4954002241801081,
"codeUnderstandability" : 0.5097926088255464,
"children" : [ {
"name" : "ch.fhnw.autofeedback.exercise",
"similarityToProf" : 0.3196941069889655,
"codeComplexity" : 0.25202745127866466,
"programmingTime" : 0.26792213754431804,
"codeUnderstandability" : 0.64921351513576,
"children" : [ {
"name" : "ExampleProblemImpl",
"similarityToProf" : 0.5,
"codeComplexity" : 0.5,
"programmingTime" : 0.5,
"codeUnderstandability" : 0.5,
"children" : [ {
"name" : "public int max(int a, int b)",
"similarityToProf" : 0.5,
"codeComplexity" : 0.5,
"programmingTime" : 0.5,
"codeUnderstandability" : 0.5,
"children" : [ ]
} ]
} ]
}, {
"name" : "ch.fhnw.autofeedback.exercise.sorting",
"similarityToProf" : 0.5,
"codeComplexity" : 0.5,
"programmingTime" : 0.5,
"codeUnderstandability" : 0.5,
"children" : [ {
"name" : "MergeSort",
"similarityToProf" : 0.5,
"codeComplexity" : 0.5,
"programmingTime" : 0.5,
"codeUnderstandability" : 0.5,
"children" : [ {
"name" : "private void merge(int[] arr, int low, int mid, int high)",
"similarityToProf" : 0.5,
"codeComplexity" : 0.5,
"programmingTime" : 0.5,
"codeUnderstandability" : 0.5,
"children" : [ ]
}, {
"name" : "public void sort(int[] arr, int low, int high)",
"similarityToProf" : 0.5,
"codeComplexity" : 0.5,
"programmingTime" : 0.5,
"codeUnderstandability" : 0.5,
"children" : [ ]
} ]
} ]
} ]
},
"verification" : {
"resultsPerFile" : {
"ForLoop.java" : {
"isValid" : false,
"results" : [ {
"methodName" : "ch.fhnw.autofeedback.exercise.ForLoop.ForLoop()",
"isValid" : true,
"status" : [ {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 3,
"check" : "Feasibility check #1 - after static initialization ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 3,
"check" : "Feasibility check #2 - after static initial state assumption ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 3,
"check" : "Feasibility check #3 - after inherited fields ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 3,
"check" : "Feasibility check #4 - after allocation assumption ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 3,
"check" : "Feasibility check #5 - after invariants for receiver of ForLoop() ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 3,
"check" : "Feasibility check #6 - end of preconditions ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 3,
"check" : "Feasibility check #7 - before call ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 3,
"check" : "Feasibility check #8 - after call ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 1,
"check" : "Feasibility check #9 - at implicit return ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
}, {
"file" : "/work/ForLoop.java",
"line" : 1,
"check" : "Feasibility check #10 - at program exit ",
"result" : " OK [0.00 secs]"
} ],
"warnings" : [ ],
"endLineNr" : 14,
"feedback" : "Feasibility check #1 - after static initialization OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #2 - after static initial state assumption OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #3 - after inherited fields OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #4 - after allocation assumption OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #5 - after invariants for receiver of ForLoop() OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #6 - end of preconditions OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #7 - before call OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #8 - after call OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #9 - at implicit return OK [0.00 secs]\nFeasibility check #10 - at program exit OK [0.00 secs]\n"
}, {
"methodName" : "ch.fhnw.autofeedback.exercise.ForLoop.forloop(int)",
"isValid" : false,
"status" : [ ],
"warnings" : [ {
"endLineNr" : 67,
"warning" : "/work/ForLoop.java:10: verify The prover cannot establish an assertion (Postcondition /work/ForLoop.java:6:) in method forloop\n return x;\n ^\n/work/ForLoop.java:6: verify Associated declaration /work/ForLoop.java:10:\n ensures \\result == 0;\n ^\n",
"trace" : "/work/ForLoop.java:1: \trequires true; \n\t\t\tVALUE true\t === true\n/work/ForLoop.java:5: \trequires x == -15; \n\t\t\tVALUE x\t === ( - 15 )\n\t\t\tVALUE -15\t === ( - 15 )\n\t\t\tVALUE x == -15\t === true\n/work/ForLoop.java:10: \treturn x;\n/work/ForLoop.java:6: \tensures \\result == 0; \n\t\t\tVALUE \\result\t === ( - 15 )\n\t\t\tVALUE 0\t === 0\n\t\t\tVALUE \\result == 0\t === false\n/work/ForLoop.java:10: Invalid assertion (Postcondition)\n /work/ForLoop.java:6: Associated location\n",
"counterexample" : "`THIS = |`THIS|\nx_0_0___7 = 0\nASSERT_41_136 = true\njava.lang.Object_`alloc___47_0___5 = ( store ( ( as const ( Array REF Int ) ) 0 ) REF!val!6 ( - 38 ) )\nASSERT_43_136 = true\n`exception_136_136___8 = NULL\n__JML_FeasCheck_ = 0\n`THIS = |`THIS|\nch.fhnw.autofeedback.exercise.ForLoop__heap___0_136___12 = 2\nPre_2_83_72___13 = true\nASSERT_33_136 = true\nASSERT_45_136 = true\nASSERT_39_136 = true\nASSERT_47_136 = true\n_JML__tmp`6 = true\nASSERT_29_136 = true\njava.lang.Object_`isalloc___47_0___6 = ( ( as const ( Array REF Bool ) ) true )\nASSERT_38_136 = true\nASSERT_32_136 = true\njava.lang.Object_theHashCode_2969_0___2 = ( ( as const ( Array REF Int ) ) ( - 2147475929 ) )\nx_148_148___10 = ( - 15 )\nASSERT_40_136 = true\njava.lang.Object___owner_2072_0___3 = ( ( as const ( Array REF REF ) ) REF!val!6 )\n_JML__tmp`7 = true\n`terminationPosition_136_136___9 = 0\n`result_136_136___11 = 0\n"
} ],
"endLineNr" : 68,
"feedback" : "Attention the line numbers are calculated and could be wrong!\n/work/ForLoop.java:10: verify The prover cannot establish an assertion (Postcondition /work/ForLoop.java:6:) in method forloop\n return x;\n ^\n/work/ForLoop.java:6: verify Associated declaration /work/ForLoop.java:10:\n ensures \\result == 0;\n ^\n%%TRACE%%/work/ForLoop.java:1: \trequires true; \n\t\t\tVALUE true\t === true\n/work/ForLoop.java:5: \trequires x == -15; \n\t\t\tVALUE x\t === ( - 15 )\n\t\t\tVALUE -15\t === ( - 15 )\n\t\t\tVALUE x == -15\t === true\n/work/ForLoop.java:10: \treturn x;\n/work/ForLoop.java:6: \tensures \\result == 0; \n\t\t\tVALUE \\result\t === ( - 15 )\n\t\t\tVALUE 0\t === 0\n\t\t\tVALUE \\result == 0\t === false\n/work/ForLoop.java:10: Invalid assertion (Postcondition)\n /work/ForLoop.java:6: Associated location\n%%ENDTRACE%%"
} ]
}
}
},
"performance" : {
"performance" : {
"ch.fhnw.autofeedback.exercise.sorting.MergeSortRunner" : {
"complexities" : [ "O(n)", "O(n log n)" ],
"measurements" : [ {
"problemSize" : 100000,
"runs" : 118,
"duration" : 2015
}, {
"problemSize" : 200000,
"runs" : 57,
"duration" : 2014
}, {
"problemSize" : 400000,
"runs" : 27,
"duration" : 2000
}, {
"problemSize" : 800000,
"runs" : 13,
"duration" : 2024
}, {
"problemSize" : 1040000,
"runs" : 10,
"duration" : 2100
}, {
"problemSize" : 1280000,
"runs" : 8,
"duration" : 2003
}, {
"problemSize" : 1520000,
"runs" : 7,
"duration" : 2149
}, {
"problemSize" : 1600000,
"runs" : 7,
"duration" : 2274
}, {
"problemSize" : 1760000,
"runs" : 6,
"duration" : 2145
}, {
"problemSize" : 2000000,
"runs" : 5,
"duration" : 2058
}, {
"problemSize" : 2240000,
"runs" : 5,
"duration" : 2319
}, {
"problemSize" : 2480000,
"runs" : 4,
"duration" : 2083
} ]
}
}
},
"unitTest" : {
"tests" : [ {
"name" : "testMax()",
"status" : "PASSED",
"message" : null
} ]
}
}
}